Newspace 2010

Keith's note: You can watch Newspace 2010 live at Spacevidcast. You can follow it on here on Twitter as well. One interesting comment this morning from NASA HQ's Charles Miller: "NASA admits that it is not a reliable customer".

Alas, these panels are almost exclusively composed of white males in their late 40's/early 50's. No females and rarely a darker shade of skin are to be found. I know these folks, so this is most certainly not a matter of discrimination by any means. Rather, it is evidence of a total lack of imagination in terms of outreach, mentoring, and trying to embrace the real world within which space commerce is but a miniscule part. I have watched/attended these Space Frontier Foundation things year after year. Without fail, its always the same people talking about the same stuff. Lots of arm waving - but rarely any concrete solutions.

NASA is always cast as simultaneously being the enemy and the source of funds for everyone's pet project. Same thing goes for Congress. No attempt is made to get outside the box and try and be relevant to the real world and the economic, societal, and political forces that make things work. The Space Frontier Foundation used to have some radical thinking. Now it has all evaporated away. All that's left is what you see on these panels - old thinking.

If your new business idea depends on government handouts and/or favoritism then you don't have the right product or the right business plan. You are just chasing after a new flavor of pork.


Advertise Here

6 Comments

| Leave a comment

"it is evidence of a total lack of" anyone caring except space nerds.

This is also why the politicians, not these folks, have their way with NASA.

And why only those space nerds are capable of making our hopes come true...

Keith,

Great post and I agree 100%. Well said. Nothing new has come from the SFF since the early 1990's and the New Space they promote is about nothing more then merely creating "New Space contractors" to serve NASA. That is why I stopped going to the conferences years ago. I realized it was just the same group of people, with the same old ideas, over and over again.

Really there is nothing as toxic to the innovative spirit of an entrepreneurial start-up then government contracts. Although looking like easy money the hoops firms must jump through to win them just distracts them from pursuing true commercial markets and developing the same out of the box thinking and business models that drove the early PC and eCommerce industries.


The Space Frontier Foundation used to have some radical thinking. Now it has all evaporated away. All that's left is what you see on these panels - old thinking.

Keith, I'm not out at NewSpace, unfortunately. While I agree with your concern expressed in the first part above, what is the "old thinking" the participants are expressing, vs. the 'new thinking' you wish was being expressed?

In general I tend to mostly agree with your missives (65%), or disagree (35%). But now I've got an additional 10% category: "Confused".

Dave

Keith-

That review was a crackup! I'm not surprised.

I checked out their website a few times and their editorials are nutty.

For some reason I picture their conference as a cross between a tea party rally and a Star Trek convention.

The best coverage of Newspace 2010 I've seen so far has been over at Clark Lindsay's place, where he's been dutifully summarizing quite a few of the sessions:

http://www.hobbyspace.com/nucleus/index.php?catid=25

Based on the summaries, it looks like quite a bit of interesting stuff has been discussed this year. It's too bad I couldn't have been there myself. (I also happen to be one of the people possessing a "darker shade of skin")

I was actually there and on a panel requested by NASA describing possibly barriers to low coast access to space. The background your article misses is that 1) the conference was in Sunnyvale so it was very close to NASA Ames 2) NASA was a major sponsor and 3) NASA requested several specific panels about things they could do to help.

The one that I was on concerned whether or not there were technological, policy, or financial barriers to low cost access to space that NASA could somehow fix. Well, not really a panel, more like we led a discussion with the audience. There seemed to be a consensus of the NASA people that NASA was a "bad customer" whereas all of the commercial people in the room and on the panel disagreed. NASA is a fine customer. NASA's customers (Congress) are a bit odd but NASA is no different from any other large company.

The other point that was made repeatedly was that if your business case requires NASA as a customer in order to close then you really should pick another business. No one was going hat in hand asking NASA to give them $30 billion to go build their shiny new moon base. If that's what you think the conference was about then you might have come to the Spacevidcast video with some preconceived notions.

Leave a comment




calendar

Events
Launches
Your Event

Monthly Archives

Mortgage Lead

Play online bingo at the top bingo sites.

Interested in Space Travel, try the next best thing, name your own star.

Online Bingo

Hier finden Sie die neuesten Casino Bonus Codes von fuhrenden Gaming-Sites.

Forex like a Pro with a leading forex broker.

About this Entry

This page contains a single entry by Keith Cowing published on July 24, 2010 1:42 PM.

Someone Hacked @NASA_Astronauts Twitter Account was the previous entry in this blog.

Signing From Orbit is the next entry in this blog.

Find recent content on the main index or look in the archives to find all content.



- Find brilliant bingo sites and start to win

-

- Trade Forex like a Pro

- Die besten Seiten fur online roulette spielen, Spielstrategien und Tipps.